I think Liefeld is more hated than he deserves: sure he's a terrible artist who achieved totally undeserved success but I think we can all agree that it isn't his fault. He was just drawing retarded proportions and pouches in the right place at the right time.
We made him successful by buying everything he drew and then when we all realized how bad he was we got embarassed and ashamed that we made this guy rich so now we revile him.
Don't get me wrong, the dude is a hack. But we as readers are totally reponsible for the cow haunch shaped Captain A up there.
If you haven't seen this site here it's well worth checking out. If not for just the amazing way he's broken down every foul inch of his drawing style.
We here at Wednesday Warriors take full responsibility for the excessive shoulder padding and pouches and buying into it in every way.
You guys asked why Rob Liefeld ever became popular. I can't say that I really know *why*, but I do have an observation that might shed some light on the question.
Liefeld gained popularity at a time when every creative field was suddenly obsessed with doing it all WRONG-- with just abandoning the polish and the rules and breaking their medium. Grunge music was taking off, David Carson and Ray Gun magazine was dominating the design scene...
Interesting point Daniel, but it's also interesting how Grunge still stands up today and David Carson's work on Raygun is still something to behold. But there's not as much love these days for the Liefeld work.
Maybe in another 10 years he's be recognized for his greatness.
Wednesday Warriors is for everyone who is counting down the days every week until it is Wednesday and the new weekly comic books hit the stands. With discussions about what is going on in the industry, reviews of current and older comics and a wide variety of opinions from well-read fans. The Warriors are: Sean Leslie, Sean Hennefer, Jonas Wilkinson, Bryton Sampson, and John Powell.
I love the image you used for this podcast.
ReplyDeleteI think Liefeld is more hated than he deserves: sure he's a terrible artist who achieved totally undeserved success but I think we can all agree that it isn't his fault. He was just drawing retarded proportions and pouches in the right place at the right time.
We made him successful by buying everything he drew and then when we all realized how bad he was we got embarassed and ashamed that we made this guy rich so now we revile him.
Don't get me wrong, the dude is a hack. But we as readers are totally reponsible for the cow haunch shaped Captain A up there.
We couldn't agree more.
ReplyDeleteIf you haven't seen this site here it's well worth checking out. If not for just the amazing way he's broken down every foul inch of his drawing style.
We here at Wednesday Warriors take full responsibility for the excessive shoulder padding and pouches and buying into it in every way.
Thanks for your comment man enjoy the podcast!
You guys asked why Rob Liefeld ever became popular. I can't say that I really know *why*, but I do have an observation that might shed some light on the question.
ReplyDeleteLiefeld gained popularity at a time when every creative field was suddenly obsessed with doing it all WRONG-- with just abandoning the polish and the rules and breaking their medium. Grunge music was taking off, David Carson and Ray Gun magazine was dominating the design scene...
Liefeld fit in that moment-- know what I mean?
I do know exactly what you mean.
ReplyDeleteI think we will never truly understand the exact reasons how it came to be I'm just glad it did.
Thanks for listening!
Interesting point Daniel, but it's also interesting how Grunge still stands up today and David Carson's work on Raygun is still something to behold. But there's not as much love these days for the Liefeld work.
ReplyDeleteMaybe in another 10 years he's be recognized for his greatness.